Higher-Level Review Explained

Think the VA made an error in your claim decision? Learn how Higher-Level Review works and when requesting a second review may be appropriate.

VA Higher-Level Review Explained: When and How to Request One

Receiving an unfavorable VA disability decision can be frustrating, especially when a veteran believes the evidence already submitted should have supported a different outcome. Fortunately, an initial decision is not always the final opportunity to seek review.

The VA offers several decision review pathways, including Higher-Level Review (HLR). Knowing when this option is appropriate can help veterans and advocates make informed decisions without unnecessarily repeating the claims process.

 


 

What Is a VA Higher-Level Review?

A Higher-Level Review allows a more senior VA reviewer to reconsider a previous decision using the evidence that was available when the decision under review was made.

The process is designed to identify errors in the prior decision. For example, an HLR may be appropriate when a veteran believes that the VA overlooked relevant evidence already in the record or incorrectly applied a regulation.

The key limitation is that new evidence cannot generally be introduced during a Higher-Level Review.

 


 

When Should You Consider Higher-Level Review?

Higher-Level Review may be appropriate when:

  • Important evidence was already submitted but appears to have been overlooked.
  • A regulation or rating criterion may have been applied incorrectly.
  • An existing medical opinion may have been evaluated improperly.
  • The decision contains an error concerning an issue already supported by the record.

An advocate should first study the decision letter, the evidence considered, and the reasons VA provided. Not every disagreement demonstrates a reviewable error. The goal is to identify the specific issue requiring reconsideration.

 


 

Higher-Level Review vs. Supplemental Claim

These two review options serve different purposes.

Higher-Level Review Supplemental Claim
Reconsiders the existing evidentiary record Allows new and relevant evidence
Focuses on identifying decision errors Focuses on reconsideration with additional support
New evidence is generally not accepted New and relevant evidence is required
Uses VA Form 20-0996 Uses VA Form 20-0995

If a previously denied claim now has important new medical documentation, a Supplemental Claim may be more appropriate.

If the existing evidence was sufficient but may have been misinterpreted or overlooked, Higher-Level Review may deserve consideration.

 


 

The Informal Conference Option

Veterans or their representatives may request an optional informal conference as part of Higher-Level Review. During this conversation, the claimant or representative can identify specific errors in the earlier decision. 

It is not an opportunity to submit new evidence. A productive informal conference focuses on the relevant issues, the existing record, and why reconsideration is warranted.

 


 

How to Request Higher-Level Review

For eligible decisions, the process generally involves submitting VA Form 20-0996 and identifying the specific issues being challenged. For many decisions, the request must be received within one year of the decision letter.

Review the official eligibility requirements before submitting the form. Once the request is accepted, the VA conducts its review and issues a decision. It may also identify a duty-to-assist error requiring additional development.

 


 

Common Higher-Level Review Mistakes

The most common mistake is requesting HLR when the underlying problem is missing evidence. Other mistakes include failing to identify a specific error, overlooking applicable deadlines, and assuming that an informal conference functions like an evidentiary hearing.

A vague disagreement is less useful than a focused explanation of why the existing record warrants a different decision.

 


 

Final Thoughts

Higher-Level Review can be a valuable option when a veteran believes an existing decision contains an error. However, it is not the right pathway for every denial. 

The strongest review request begins with understanding why the previous decision was made.

Explore Volume II for more advanced guidance on VA decision reviews and appeals.